How to Download and Fill Form 15G for PF Withdrawal Online

Global employment often results in individuals contributing to retirement funds outside India.

Once they return and qualify as Indian residents, the taxation of those foreign retirement accounts creates significant challenges. The mismatch between Indian tax law and foreign jurisdictional rules frequently leads to double taxation or premature tax exposure.

Section 89A of the Income Tax Act addresses this issue. Introduced in the Union Budget 2021, it aligns Indian tax treatment of such accounts with the taxation rules in the foreign country where the retirement benefits are held.

Section 89A of Income Tax Act offers a practical framework that prevents residents from being taxed twice on the same stream of income.

Understanding Section 89A of the Income Tax Act

Section 89A of the Income Tax Act is a special provision designed for residents who maintain retirement accounts abroad. In several countries, including the United States, the United Kingdom, and Canada, contributions to retirement savings are tax-deferred and taxable only at withdrawal. Indian law historically taxed such income on an accrual basis, creating misalignment.

Under Section 89A of income tax, the income from these accounts is taxed in India in the year it becomes taxable in the foreign jurisdiction, not earlier. The provision eliminates the risk of dual taxation across different timeframes.

This reform matters to returning professionals who have accumulated pensions, 401(k)s, IRAs, or similar retirement accounts abroad. Without it, they would face taxation in India on accrued income even when those funds remained inaccessible.

Why Section 89A Was Introduced

Cross-border employment created unique challenges in Indian taxation well before Section 89A came into effect. Professionals working abroad contributed to retirement accounts such as pension schemes, 401(k) plans in the United States, or Registered Retirement Savings Plans (RRSPs) in Canada.

These accounts were typically structured to defer tax until withdrawal. Once such individuals returned to India and became residents, the domestic tax regime took a different view.

Before Section 89A, taxpayers returning to India often encountered two critical issues:

Double Taxation Burden

India’s tax laws traditionally taxed income on an accrual basis. This meant that notional growth, interest, or accretions within a foreign retirement account could be taxed annually in India, even though the individual had not withdrawn the funds. At the same time, the foreign jurisdiction taxed the account at the time of withdrawal.

The outcome was a classic double taxation scenario:

• In India, tax liability arose each year on unrealised gains
• In the foreign country, tax liability arose later when the individual actually withdrew the funds

This mismatch placed returning residents in an unfavourable position where the same income stream suffered taxation in two different years under two separate regimes.

Liquidity and Cash Flow Constraints

nother practical problem involved cash flow. Individuals were required to discharge tax liabilities in India before receiving any corresponding inflow from their foreign retirement account. For example, an expatriate returning to India might have no access to their pension until retirement age in the foreign country, but still face annual Indian tax bills on notional accruals.

Such a framework created significant liquidity strain: taxpayers were forced to allocate domestic resources to pay tax on income that remained locked in overseas accounts. For retirees or those relying on savings, this created unnecessary financial pressure.

Need for Alignment with International Practices

Tax regimes worldwide generally ensure that retirement accounts are taxed at the point of withdrawal, aligning taxation with actual income realisation. India’s previous treatment diverged from this principle.

The absence of alignment also created frequent disputes, as taxpayers attempted to claim relief under Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAAs), often leading to prolonged litigation.

Section 89A of Income Tax Act provisions were designed as a corrective measure. The government recognised the inequity faced by returning residents and introduced a rule that synchronised Indian taxation with the foreign jurisdiction’s timing of taxation.

Policy Objectives Behind the Provision

The policy objectives of Section 89A are clear:

• Equity: Ensure returning residents are not taxed disproportionately compared to peers who remain abroad.
• Certainty: Reduce interpretational disputes by establishing a uniform rule for notified foreign retirement accounts.
• Compliance: Encourage transparent reporting of overseas accounts by reducing the perceived unfairness of double taxation.
• Competitiveness: Strengthen India’s position as a favourable destination for repatriated talent by addressing a long-standing pain point.

In effect, Section 89A brought Indian law in line with global practices, allowing residents to pay tax in India only when their foreign retirement account is actually taxed abroad. This reform not only improved fairness but also simplified compliance for thousands of individuals navigating complex cross-border financial obligations.

Eligibility for Relief Under Section 89A

Key Requirements

Relief under Section 89A is available only when specific conditions are satisfied:

Notified Countries

At present, the government has notified countries such as the United States, the United Kingdom, and Canada. Only accounts located in these jurisdictions are covered. Future notifications may expand the scope, but taxpayers must verify eligibility each year.

Key Provisions of Section 89A

Applicable Income

Relief under Section 89A is restricted to retirement benefit accounts maintained in specified foreign jurisdictions. These are accounts designed for long-term savings, with contributions often made during years of employment abroad. They generally enjoy tax deferral until the time of withdrawal in the foreign country.

Examples include:

• Pension schemes operated by foreign employers or governments
• US-based 401(k) or IRA accounts, which accumulate earnings on a tax-deferred basis
• Canadian RRSPs, UK pension funds, or equivalent retirement savings vehicles in other notified countries

Ordinary investment accounts, brokerage holdings, or deposits abroad do not qualify. Section 89A focuses exclusively on retirement savings that are structurally taxed on a deferred basis abroad.

Assessment Year Applicability

The provisions of Section 89A became effective starting Assessment Year 2022-23, which corresponds to income earned in the Financial Year 2021-22. From this point onward, Indian residents can invoke Section 89A relief, provided all conditions are met.

This timing is significant because it sets a clear cut-off. Retirement income accrued prior to Financial Year 2021-22 would not benefit from Section 89A, unless separately covered under Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements.

Alignment Rule

The central mechanism of Section 89A is the synchronisation of taxation between India and the foreign country. In practical terms, this means:

• If the foreign country taxes the retirement account only upon withdrawal, India will also wait to levy tax until that withdrawal year
• If the foreign jurisdiction has a different structure (for example, partial taxation during accrual), India mirrors that timing rather than applying its own accrual-based approach

This alignment ensures the taxpayer is not penalised simply because of a difference in timing rules across jurisdictions. It transforms the taxation principle from an accrual-based system to a realisation-based system, but only for eligible foreign retirement accounts.

How Section 89A Differs from Section 89

Taxpayers sometimes confuse Section 89A with Section 89. Their purposes, however, differ materially:

• Section 89: Grants relief when salary arrears or advances push taxpayers into higher brackets. It spreads the tax burden across the years to which the income relates.
• Section 89A: Applies exclusively to retirement accounts held in specified foreign countries and aligns taxation years across jurisdictions.

Correct classification is critical during income tax e filing to avoid errors or disputes during assessment.

Process to Claim Relief Under Section 89A

Claiming relief requires following a structured process:

• Step 1: Identify qualifying income: Confirm that the source is a notified foreign retirement benefits account.
• Step 2: Compute Indian liability: Calculate tax liability as if the income were taxable under Indian rules for the year.
• Step 3: Determine foreign taxation year: Establish the year in which the foreign jurisdiction taxes the account.
• Step 4: File accurately: While filing the income tax return, disclose the income under Section 89A and claim alignment with foreign taxation.

Practical Example of Relief Under Section 89A

Consider an Indian citizen who worked in the United States for 15 years and contributed to a 401(k). After relocating permanently to India in 2022, the account continued to accrue returns.

• Under Indian rules, tax would normally apply each year on accrual basis
• In the United States, tax applies only at withdrawal, often post-retirement

If withdrawals begin in 2025, US taxation occurs then. Section 89A ensures Indian taxation also occurs in 2025, not in prior years, preventing double taxation across timelines.

Documents Required to Claim Relief

Taxpayers seeking relief must maintain:

• Evidence of Indian residency for the financial year
• Statements of the foreign retirement account
• Certificates confirming taxability in the foreign country
• Declaration opting for relief under Section 89A

Accurate documentation streamlines compliance and reduces scrutiny during assessment.

Important Conditions and Limitations

Section 89A provides targeted relief but within boundaries:

• Relief applies only to retirement accounts, not to other forms of overseas investment
• Only accounts in notified countries qualify
• Taxpayers must formally opt in through the prescribed process
• If a Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) offers more favourable treatment, taxpayers may evaluate both and choose accordingly

Clarity on these conditions avoids incorrect claims and ensures compliance with the income tax act.

Tax Planning with Section 89A

Effective planning can enhance the benefit of Section 89A:

Timing Withdrawals

Taxpayers may plan withdrawals from foreign retirement accounts in a manner consistent with Indian tax slabs. Spreading withdrawals across years can help optimise tax liability.

Evaluating DTAA Interaction

For some countries, DTAA provisions may offer tax credits or exemptions superior to Section 89A relief. Comparing both frameworks is essential.

Leveraging Digital Tools

Simulation tools, such as a tax calculator can project tax implications under different scenarios, enabling more informed retirement planning.

Final Thoughts

Section 89A of Income Tax creates a consistent framework for taxing foreign retirement accounts of Indian residents. It eliminates the inequity of taxing income before it is realised abroad and provides relief from double taxation.

For individuals returning after years of employment overseas, the provision safeguards retirement wealth. Relief under Section 89A, supported by correct filing and robust documentation, helps preserve capital while ensuring compliance with the Income Tax Act. It stands as an important advancement in India’s cross-border tax policy, offering clarity and security to global professionals returning home.

Related Articles:

Income Tax on Pension - What Is Taxable & What You Can Exempt
Pension Retirement Plan to Fund You Post Retirement
Types of Pension Plans: How to Choose for Your Retirement
Limitations of Tax Planning: Tax Planning Challenges
Tax Planning: Tax Planning Guide and Tips in India